jdfish,
I wanted you to check your settings to ensure you didn't inadvertently set them to something that would be affecting your performance.
Ping speed normally starts at 50% and chart speed at 100%. When I'm slowly going along, picking apart a weedline or lilly pad field, I've often times dropped my chart speed to 87% (one click down) and it gives me a better picture. If I'm just chunking and winding, I have it set to 100% chart speed.
Sometimes (not often), I'll bring up the ping speed to 75%, but I'm also playing around with the sensitivity at the same time.
You stated that you keep the sensitivity on manual to reduce clutter. Do you periodically make changes to it? Unless you are fishing in a swimming pool, the bottom consistancy changes, so you will more than likely be making minor changes to the sensitivity during the day. I put mine in manual sensitivity and then bring it up until my screen starts getting cluttered. Then I start gradually backing it down until I get the best possible picture.
Noise rejection is used for many factors, including engine noise, other electronics, etc... The reason I asked about noise rejection and surface clarity is that the higher you set them - the more you are killing your signal. Basically, you could be reducing your sensitivity to the point that you wouldn't see anything and could possibly lose signal quite often.
All the best,
Glenn